Losing the Battle for Hearts and Minds

It’s greatly concerning to learn that during the very period the church has most aggressively pursued a strategy that emphasizes growth in numbers, it has also seen continued and exponential decline in size.

In a previous post, I compared this situation with the American policy of relying on body counts during the Vietnam War. As Ken Burns’ recent documentary series points out, while the body count made it look as though the US was winning the war, they were in fact heading toward certain defeat. That was in part because of the American inability to win the hearts and minds of the people of South Vietnam.

Not that the USA didn’t know this at the time. They had instituted an operation called “Winning Hearts and Minds” (yep, the acronym is WHAM) to pacify the increasingly disillusioned South Vietnamese. After all, there was no point killing more North Vietnamese forces if the very people you’re fighting for – the South – despise you.

As we now know, that was exactly the situation.

American ignorance and arrogance put the South Vietnamese off-side from the beginning. So did their support for a corrupt and incompetent South Vietnamese government. But one of the greatest problems for Operation WHAM was the immorality of the American GIs.

Saigon was turned into a cesspool of prostitution and drug-taking. The South Vietnamese president begged the Americans to clean up the city and the US army responded with Operation MOOSE (Move Out Of Saigon Expeditiously), where soldiers were stationed in camps outside the city. It didn’t work. The Americans were telling the South they were there to help them build a better society while showing no evidence of it themselves.

Could it be that while the church is busy counting members or attendees, we are losing the hearts and minds of our nation?

Instead of counting butts on pews, maybe the church should start counting the cost of not embodying the values we are trying to promote to our broader society. Several recent stories could be submitted as evidence.

Sexual Abuse: Andy Savage and Highpoint Church

Twenty years ago, as a youth pastor, Andy Savage coerced a teenager under his care to participate in sexual activity with him. The victim Jules Woodson has said that Savage became remorseful immediately after the incident, apologizing and begging her to keep quiet about the whole thing. She claimed that the church also instructed her to say nothing.

Savage moved on. Today he is the teaching pastor at Highpoint Church, a megachurch in Memphis.

Woodson did not move on. Unable to live with her silence any longer, she recently reached out to Savage, triggering him to make a preemptive public confession of what he termed a “sexual incident” to his congregation. He didn’t deny any of the story, and expressed contrition for his behavior, and for this, his church gave him a standing ovation.

The standing ovation heard around the world, as Ed Stetzer called it.

How are we meant to win the hearts and minds of secular society when congregations of Christian people give abusers standing ovations. To quote Ed Stetzer again, “No one should ever receive a standing ovation when it comes to alleged abuse—unless it’s directed at a victim with the courage to speak out.”

Whatever you may think about Andy Savage’s behavior 20 years ago, or his treatment of Ms Woodson since, that congregational ovation just lost us a lot of hearts and minds.

Unreasonable force: Reggie Hilts

Reggie Hilts is a pastor at The Sanctuary of Worship church in Louisiana. He supplements his income by working as a sergeant with the Abbeville City Marshal’s Office. He was on duty recently during a heated school board meeting where English teacher Deyshia Hargrave was asking why the superintendent had received a raise when lowly paid teachers and support staff have not. The board clearly didn’t want to answer uncomfortable questions like that and asked her to sit down. But, as is her right, Ms Hargrave persisted in her questioning.

That’s when Pastor Reggie Hilts stepped in.

The video of him manhandling the English teacher from the meeting, slamming her into a wall, throwing her to the floor, handcuffing her, and marching her out of the building, went viral.

It has since come to light that Hilts was previously sued by a 62-year-old man who claimed Hilts slammed him head first onto the concrete, cutting his head and fracturing his ribs.

Deyshia Hargrave has stated that she holds no animosity toward Hilts and won’t be suing, and the school board didn’t press any charges against her for speaking out at the meeting (nor should they). However, it looks pretty bad when a man whose own church website speaks of him being filled with the Holy Spirit, and devoted to “much prayer and fasting,” behaves this way. Especially toward an award-winning teacher exercising her democratic right to free speech at a public meeting. What on earth got into him?

I’m not suggesting Christians can’t work in law enforcement, but it was totally unacceptable for Pastor Hilts to use such unreasonable force against a woman who was not resisting him.

More hearts and minds lost.

Xenophobia: Robert Jeffress

President Donald Trump has incurred a great deal of public criticism for his alleged reference to Haiti and certain African nations as “shithole countries” from which America should not accept immigrants. This follows his campaign statements that Mexico was sending criminals and rapists to America, his attempted Muslim travel ban, as well as his too-soft denunciation of neo-Nazis marching in Charlottesville, and his retweeting of libellous and racist videos from the Britain First group. Recently, his decision to end Temporary Protected Status (TPS) for 200,000 Salvadoran immigrants has created enormous anxiety across the country.

What is a man of God to do in light of this behavior?

Well, it seems the president can always count on the support of the pastor of First Baptist Dallas, Robert Jeffress. Right on cue, Jeffress has waded in to endorse Mr Trump’s views: “Apart from the vocabulary attributed to him, President Trump is right on target in his sentiment.” According to Jeffress, while Christians do have a duty to “place the needs of others above our own,” that doesn’t extend to the president.

When megachurch pastors stand alongside former Ku Klux Klan leaders, white supremacists and Alt-Right frontmen in praising Mr Trump for these statements, we can be sure people are questioning whether the church embodies the values of Christ anymore. As Howard Snyder has written, “Many Evangelicals have forgotten the meaning of apostasy, which means not heresy but departing from the Gospel in practice and/or belief. The opposite of apostleship and discipleship.”

I don’t know Andy Savage, Reggie Hilts or Robert Jeffress personally. They are my brothers in Christ. They might be great guys, for all I know. But when the church, or its representatives are in the news for incidents of sexual abuse, excessive force against a woman, or the endorsement of xenophobia, you know it’s been a bad week in the battle to win the hearts and minds of everyday people.

When US forces in Vietnam attempted operations like WHAM and MOOSE they failed miserably. The rot had set in. And once they lost the confidence of the South Vietnamese there was no way to win it back.

We can only pray the church in the West hasn’t passed the point of no return in winning the hearts and minds of their neighbors too.

Share to:
Losing the Battle for Hearts and Minds

Subscribe to my blog


The views expressed are my own and do not necessarily represent the official views of Morling College or its affiliates and partners.

Latest Blogs

Picturing the Resurrection

The best paintings of the resurrection don’t include Jesus in them. At least it seems that way. Seven years ago (was it really that long??)

The Perfect Ash Wednesday Picture

What an eccentric painting this is. Carl Spitzweg’s 1860 painting Ash Wednesday depicts a clown, dressed presumably for Mardi Gras, languishing in a dark and

The Fierce Mother Heart of God

My three-year-old grandson Jarrah has been unwell recently. Really unwell. He has been seriously ill with what we’ve now discovered was a horrible combination of

8 thoughts on “Losing the Battle for Hearts and Minds

  1. Yes, a very bad week. This is also the reason why my son, a philosophy major in college, veers away from church at this point in his life. I got a taste of it myself last week in a local gathering of church leaders and pastors (over 200 in attendance) where nothing short of “The Gospel According to American Sniper” was promoted in a church safety seminar. I’m not sure I can be as charitable as you are in your post. I’m not sure I can call much of this Christian. Jesus’ way (let alone Jesus himself) doesn’t figure in the equations.

    1. Ugh on both accounts – your son and that church “safety” seminar. I’ll pray that your boy pulls through with his faith in tact. It’s tough that the church is more hindrance than help when it comes to holding onto faith as you journey into adulthood (and adult faith). Peace.
      ps. Maybe you should avoid those safety seminars in future. 😉

      1. Will do!

  2. Thank you Michael for shining a light on these events and people. I very much resonate with the definition of apostasy. What the non church world is longing for are followers of Jesus whose actions match their proclaimed faith.

    1. I find myself wanting to apologise on behalf of Jesus to nonbelievers for the ugly acts of those of us who represent Him on Earth.
      There have been times when I have actually said sorry- like when Joel Osteen refused to offer his church as sanctuary from the floods in Texas (he did eventually do so but only after it was called to the medias attention) or when a New Zealand Pastor claimed local earthquakes as punishment for homosexuality in NZ.
      When I say sorry I also admit that I have often failed to show the face of Christ though I try my best to be a good Christian.
      I’ve found my nonbeliver friends to respond graciously, a knowledging they realise the actions of some do not reflect the heart of Christ. But I think its important for Christians to speak up and acknowledge when one of our own has failed to hold up the loving and merciful standards God has shared with us through Christ.
      I don’t mean in an overcritical way but certainly in a way that lets nonbelievers know God is not ok with this type of behaviour.

      The article you did a few months ago on two different types of Christianity fighting it out in public- one that pushed for recognition and its rights as a religion (I think you wrote it in responce to the public prayer bann in American football) and the other fighting for social justice, was a brilliant critique and certainly helped me identify what it was that angered me when Western Christians backed Trump or complained about the right to public prayer. In that piece you said there was some sort of middle ground to be met by both sides- I haven’t quite yet discovered that middle ground but acknowledging the failures of certain Christians with a heartfelt apology and letting nonbelievers know that certain actions are not in accord with Christ seems to help a bit.

  3. I don’t quite see the point. There are rightists ad leftists in the population. Rightists may be offended by leftist pastors, leaving the church – or may be content that there are some rightist pastors staying. Leftists may be offended by rightist pastors being in the church – or may be content that there are some leftist pastors staying.
    The interesting question is : Has Jesus any message which is joyful for everyone, rightists and leftists?

    1. It must be idyllic to live in such a simplistic world where you can just categorize everyone as a “leftist” or a “rightist”. I’ll leave you there in the comfort of your ignorance.

  4. I agree with these sentiments. Hypocrisy is at the root of these things. It certainly comes down to all sides of the aisle. To support and cheer on candidates who are openly in favor of abortion is just as egregious. It is unarguable that this is the epitome of sending the wrong message to the world and accepting evil in our midst.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *